Download Ebook The Theory of Cultural and Social Selection, by W. G. Runciman
Now, exactly how do you know where to purchase this book The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman Don't bother, now you might not visit guide shop under the bright sun or night to browse the e-book The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman We here consistently assist you to locate hundreds sort of publication. Among them is this book qualified The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman You could visit the link web page provided in this collection and after that opt for downloading and install. It will not take more times. Merely hook up to your internet accessibility and also you could access guide The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman on-line. Obviously, after downloading and install The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman, you might not publish it.
The Theory of Cultural and Social Selection, by W. G. Runciman
Download Ebook The Theory of Cultural and Social Selection, by W. G. Runciman
Why ought to get ready for some days to get or receive the book The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman that you get? Why need to you take it if you can obtain The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman the much faster one? You could locate the same book that you order right here. This is it the book The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman that you can receive directly after buying. This The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman is well known book worldwide, of course many people will aim to own it. Why do not you come to be the first? Still perplexed with the method?
Keep your method to be below as well as read this resource completed. You can appreciate looking guide The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman that you actually refer to get. Here, obtaining the soft data of guide The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman can be done quickly by downloading and install in the link web page that we supply right here. Certainly, the The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman will certainly be all yours earlier. It's no have to get ready for guide The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman to obtain some days later on after purchasing. It's no need to go outside under the warms at center day to head to the book establishment.
This is several of the benefits to take when being the member as well as obtain the book The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman right here. Still ask exactly what's different of the other site? We give the hundreds titles that are produced by advised writers and also authors, around the globe. The connect to get and also download and install The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman is likewise quite simple. You could not find the complicated website that order to do more. So, the method for you to obtain this The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman will be so very easy, won't you?
Based on the The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman information that we provide, you may not be so baffled to be here and to be member. Obtain now the soft file of this book The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman as well as save it to be your own. You saving could lead you to stimulate the simplicity of you in reading this book The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman Also this is kinds of soft data. You could really make better opportunity to obtain this The Theory Of Cultural And Social Selection, By W. G. Runciman as the suggested book to review.
In The Theory of Cultural and Social Selection, W. G. Runciman presents an original and wide-ranging account of the fundamental process by which human cultures and societies come to be of the different kinds that they are. Drawing on and extending recent advances in neo-Darwinian evolutionary theory, Runciman argues that collective human behaviour should be analyzed as the acting-out of information transmitted at the three separate but interacting levels of heritable variation and competitive selection - the biological, the cultural, and the social. The implications which this carries for a reformulation of the traditional agenda of comparative and historical sociology are explored with the help of selected examples, and located within the context of current debates about sociological theory and practice. The Theory of Cultural and Social Selection is a succinct and highly imaginative contribution to one of the great intellectual debates of our times, from one of the world's leading social theorists.
- Sales Rank: #2627889 in Books
- Published on: 2009-12-14
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 8.98" h x .55" w x 5.98" l, 1.05 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 266 pages
Review
"Runciman's puzzle is how to bring together different levels of change and differentiation in human existence - from the biological to the social - under a single analytic framework, one that rests firmly on a Darwinian logic of selection.... With a remarkable depth and insight, Runciman can give penetrating answers to the 'why' questions." - The Times Literary Supplement
About the Author
W. G. Runciman has been a Fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge since 1971 and of the British Academy, as whose President he served from 2001-2004, since 1975. He holds honorary degrees from the Universities of Edinburgh, London, Oxford and York. He is an Honorary Fellow of Nuffield College, Oxford and a Foreign Honorary Member of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences.
Most helpful customer reviews
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful.
Sociology through meme-tinted spectacles
By Tim Tyler
e book is essentially sociology with memes. The main topic is sociology, but the terminology and explanatory framework used by the book is based on memetics.
The book covers religious and political topics. It deals with feuds, rituals, slavery, Marxism and marriage customs. It discusses stasis, group selection, convergence and the goal-directedness of social change. There are sections about the role of Darwinism in social science, resistance to Darwinism and the history of the field.
To the extent that the book has a main theme, it's that natural selection and cultural selection need extending to social selection. In the book natural selection is based on genes, cultural selection is based on memes and social selection is based on practices. Genetic traits are evoked, memetic traits are acquired and social practices are imposed. Cultural selection and social selection are said to not be reducible to natural selection.
There is a kind of case to be made along these lines. A lot of the work on the topic has been done by people interested in microevolutionary phenomena and population genetics. For them small-scale cultural phenomena are more immediate and accessible than society and history are - and they can be more easily explored experimentally. As a result, there's a bit of a bias towards psychology - and away from sociology, history and the world of cultural macroevolution. It is easy to imagine how sociologists might feel that their field is being unfairly neglected by selectionist theorists.
However, it seems to me that Runciman pushes this case to unrealistic extremes. His rejection of the term "socio-cultural evolution" seems to be unreasonable to me. I don't like his proposed terminology for social evolution either. What he calls "practices" I just call "memes" - the same term as is used for the units of cultural evolution. Using a different term makes very little sense. The author's "meme-practice evolution" terminology seems almost as bad as the "gene-culture evolution" terminology - both represent an inappropriate muddling together of different types of category.
The relationship between social evolution and small scale cultural phenomena is a lot like the relationship between micro- and macro-evolution. Macro-evolution is essentially made up of many micro-evolutionary phenonmena. It is true that there are emergent phenomena that come from considering things at a different scale. It is also true that group selection might potentially introduce new effects at the larger scale. However, group selection still seems to be relatively insignificant - and macroevolution is largely microevolution writ large.
The author mentions multi-level selection in the context of his framework. He discusses cultural group selection - and briefly attempts to sketch a case for it. However, he doesn't seem to present social selection as a synonym for cultural group selection. Group selection - if significant enough - would provide a theoretical basis for the type of split the author is going for. However, it hardly presents sociology with a firm foundation. Without being based on group selection, social selection seems to be pretty similar to cultural selection, and the emphatic split between them advocated by the author doesn't really seem to be warranted.
Next: memes. The book is saturated with memes. They are mentioned on almost every page. Runciman produces what seems to me to be a perfectly reasonable rationale for using the memetics terminology, and then views sociology with meme-tinted spectables. It would have been better if he had used it to describe social selection too. However, I think that Runciman should be praised and congratulated for adopting memes.
I can't easily review most of the sociology in the book - but I can review its memetics. The memetics in the book seems to be pretty basic. Runciman has deleterious memes, but there seems to be no the meme's eye view, or meme recombination. There's a discussion of memes as symbionts, but it draws what I think is the wrong conclusion. Runciman identifies the "viral" aspect of memetics, but then criticises it for falsely implying that memes are deleterious. He also criticises it by saying that viruses are transmitted by a single exposure, while memes may require multiple exposures that act to reinforce each other. These criticisms don't apply to other kinds of organic symbiosis, though. For example, when a lone sheep tastes a pleasing mushroom it might require multiple exposures before is acquires a taste for them and starts to actively seek them out and distrubute mushroom spores in its feces. Taking multiple exposures before a relationship with a symbiont is established is pretty common for food symbionts - and it has nothing specifically to do with cultural evolution, and so does not represent much of a disanalogy between the cultural and organic realms.
Runciman goes on to give some examples of where he thinks that the symbiosis perspective fails. The first example he gives does exhibit the logistic growth curve found in epidemiology - but Runciman says it more closely resembles detoxification that an infection. Through the lens of symbiosis, his example looks more like a case of disinfection. It is actually an example of disinfection by one cultural symbiont caused by infection with another one. There are similar phenomena in the organic realm - such as when bacteria in a pro-biotic yogurt is used to displace rogue gut bacteria. The second example describes a case where one group fails to acquire a contagion from another group - and Runciman claims that an "infection" theory would have predicted greater spread. However, there are phenomena such as adaptive and genetic immunitity to consider. The failure of some particular germ to spread doesn't invalidate the whole theory of germs. Reasoning in this way, Runciman fails to adopt the symboisis perspective and doesn't mention parasitism, mutualism or symbiosis for the rest of the boo. This is a pretty central part of memetics and is one of the main things that distinguishes it from other theories of cultural evolution.
However, for most of his applications, Runciman doesn't really need an advanced version of memetics with recombination and symbiosis. He can get by with a version based on bean-bag genetics - and that's exactly what he does.
Runciman's discussion of progress is acceptable. He at least acknowledges the phenomenon.
For me the main problem with the book was that it was dry and not very well written. Runciman writes in a rather flowery style that dances around the point with digressions and only rarely seems to get down to the meat. The book is broken up into chapters and numbered subsections. This layout doesn't really help readers who wants to skim read or flick through the book to find things of interest to them. There is only one diagram. Alas, I was rather glad when the book was over.
Unfortunately, this is not a great book. However, Runciman is one of the few sociologists who has actually got as far as adopting a selectionist perspective - and so other sociologists who might want to follow him don't have a lot of similar reading material to choose from - and so some may find something of value here. Those more interested in an evolutionary perspective probably won't find the book so useful. This is really much more a sociology book than the title might suggest.
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful.
this was good!
By Roland Delao
Thank you, this was good!
The Theory of Cultural and Social Selection, by W. G. Runciman PDF
The Theory of Cultural and Social Selection, by W. G. Runciman EPub
The Theory of Cultural and Social Selection, by W. G. Runciman Doc
The Theory of Cultural and Social Selection, by W. G. Runciman iBooks
The Theory of Cultural and Social Selection, by W. G. Runciman rtf
The Theory of Cultural and Social Selection, by W. G. Runciman Mobipocket
The Theory of Cultural and Social Selection, by W. G. Runciman Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar