Download Ebook Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press
To obtain this book Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press, you could not be so confused. This is online book Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press that can be taken its soft file. It is various with the on-line book Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press where you could purchase a book and afterwards the vendor will send out the published book for you. This is the location where you could get this Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press by online as well as after having take care of investing in, you could download Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press by yourself.
Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press
Download Ebook Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press
Just how an idea can be got? By staring at the superstars? By checking out the sea and also looking at the sea interweaves? Or by reading a book Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press Everyone will have particular particular to acquire the inspiration. For you that are passing away of books as well as always obtain the inspirations from publications, it is actually wonderful to be right here. We will show you hundreds compilations of guide Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press to read. If you similar to this Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press, you can also take it as your own.
As understood, journey as well as encounter regarding lesson, amusement, and also expertise can be acquired by only checking out a publication Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press Even it is not straight done, you could recognize even more about this life, regarding the world. We offer you this correct and also simple method to gain those all. We provide Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press and also many book collections from fictions to science in any way. Among them is this Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press that can be your partner.
Exactly what should you think more? Time to get this Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press It is simple after that. You could only sit as well as remain in your area to get this book Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press Why? It is online publication store that supply numerous collections of the referred publications. So, merely with net link, you can appreciate downloading this publication Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press and numbers of books that are looked for now. By seeing the link page download that we have provided, the book Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press that you refer a lot can be found. Merely conserve the requested book downloaded and install and afterwards you could delight in the book to check out every single time and area you desire.
It is really easy to read guide Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press in soft file in your device or computer. Once more, why should be so difficult to obtain guide Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press if you can pick the simpler one? This site will relieve you to choose as well as decide on the very best cumulative publications from one of the most wanted seller to the launched book lately. It will certainly constantly update the collections time to time. So, connect to internet as well as see this website constantly to get the brand-new publication every day. Now, this Judicial Independence In China: Lessons For Global Rule Of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press is your own.
This volume challenges the conventional wisdom about judicial independence in China and its relationship to economic growth, rule of law, human rights protection, and democracy. The volume adopts an interdisciplinary approach that places China's judicial reforms and the struggle to enhance the professionalism, authority, and independence of the judiciary within a broader comparative and developmental framework. Contributors debate the merits of international best practices and their applicability to China; provide new theoretical perspectives and empirical studies; and discuss civil, criminal, and administrative cases in urban and rural courts. This volume contributes to several fields, including law and development and the promotion of rule of law and good governance, globalization studies, neo-institutionalism and studies of the judiciary, the emerging literature on judicial reforms in authoritarian regimes, Asian legal studies, and comparative law more generally.
- Sales Rank: #1119395 in Books
- Published on: 2009-11-23
- Released on: 2010-05-13
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 8.98" h x .59" w x 5.98" l, .95 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 274 pages
Most helpful customer reviews
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful.
A forceful challenge to conventional wisdom on courts
By Arnold
Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law Promotion is a great addition to any library on the rule of law. The book challenges the conventional wisdom about the importance of judicial independence. In particular, it shows how China's government has increased judicial capacity and professionalism while still limiting independence. This is a very important finding considering that the rule of law industry spends billions of dollars promoting judicial independence in developing countries.
The book is a collection of articles written by some of the top China-law scholars in the field, both Western and Chinese. Each chapter focuses on a unique aspect of judicial independence in China, from commercial litigation to geographic case studies. Overall, the articles fit surprisingly well together with very little repetition. The book progresses from wider notions of judicial independence to more specific Chinese cases.
Here are some comments on the individual chapters:
1) "Halfway Home and a Long Way to Go" - Keith Henderson
Henderson's article introduces the conventional wisdom of the rule of law industry. It is a decent summary of this perspective. Nonetheless, the rest of the book challenges his recommendations.
2) "A New Approach for Promoting Judicial Independence" - Antoine Garapon
Judge Garapon directly provides a counterview to Henderson's article. In particular, he discusses how concepts of judicial independence differ event among Western common and civil law countries, much less a global norm applicable to all countries. This is a powerful critique of the standard rule of law perspective (which he calls "global gibberish")/
3) "The Party and the Courts" - Zhu Suli
As with his other work, Zhu provides a useful insider's view of the Chinese Communist Party and the courts, arguing that the party has done much to strengthen the courts. However, at points he takes his argument too far. For example, it is certainly not difficult to imagine that the KMT would eventually have modernized the courts, much as they had done on Taiwan.
4) "Judicial Independence in China" - Randall Peerenboom
As always, Peerenboom makes good use of statistics on China's judicial institutions. If you're not familiar with his research, this is a good overview. However, otherwise there's nothing new.
5) "A New Analytical Framework for Understanding and Promoting Judicial Independence in China" - Fu Yulin and Randall Peerenboom
Unfortunately, I didn't find this article quite as helpful. Too much discussion of policy proposals and reforms rather than original research. It was also a bit unfocused.
6) "Judicial Independence and the Company Law in the Shanghai Courts" - Nicholas Howson
Howson's study has some interesting data on the role of courts in commercial cases. In particular, he explores the extent to which Chinese courts are independent in the commercial as opposed to explicitly political context. However, it might be difficult to follow for a reader not steeped in commercial litigation concepts.
7) "Local Courts in Western China" - Stephanie Balme
Balme's article is a unique view inside rural Chinese courts. She describes the daily lives of judges, the difficulties they face, and even their diary entries. Easily the best article in the volume.
8) "The Judiciary Pushes Back" - Xin He
Xin He analyzes China's judicial politics through cases of `married out women.' In an interesting twist, judges have been reluctant to accept these cases, fearing the lack the capacity and political basis upon which to decide them. Xin shows the courts as a political actor aware of their own limitations.
9) "Corruption in China's Courts" - Ling Li
Ling's article tries to measure patterns of corruption in China's court. Not surprisingly, he concludes that crass physical intimidation are only found in the lower courts, while more subtle forms of corruption predominate among the high court judges. However, the methodology of relying on newspaper articles has many limits, particularly the fact that they don't cover all cases - a fact Ling acknowledges.
10) "Survey of Commercial Litigation in Shanghai Courts" - Minxin Pei, Zhang Guoyan, Pei Fei, and Chen Lixin
This study focuses more on litigants as strategic actors in courts. Particularly interesting is the assessment of corruption. The authors claim that many corporate clients claim to have tried to influence judges, while a significant number of private parties tried but could not figure out how to influence judges. The methodology has some problems however, particularly the potential for bias among the respondents.
11) "Judicial Independence in Authoritarian Regimes" - Carlo Guarnieri
This article had potential, but is a bit too basic. It starts off with a basic comparison of common and civil law judges - something already covered by Garapon earlier. Some of Guarnieri's examples were interesting, particularly Fascist Italy, but in the end he never goes into much detail about the court structure in his case studies.
12) "Judicial Independence in East Asia" - Tom Ginsburg
Ginsburg's discussion of judicial independence more broadly is excellent. However, I'm not convinced by the linkage to China. Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan were under the influence of the U.S. and have relatively small, homogenous populations. By contrast, China is huge and the Communist Party still insecure about its power. Eventually, Northeast Asia might provide a model, but right now I don't think it's the best referent.
While overall this is a great volume for both rule of law practitioners, readers not familiar with China's legal system already might find themselves lost during the first few chapters. Perhaps the book should have included a basic introduction to the structure of the people's courts and constitutional provisions governing them. I'd refer readers to The Legal System of the People's Republic of China in a Nutshell (West Nutshell) for a basic overview if they need an introduction.
A more serious concern about Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law Promotion is the lack of comparative law. Southern Europe and Northeast Asia might not be the best comparators for China's current state of development. Rather, the book would have benefitted from a discussion of judicial independence in other developing countries and the challenges therein. For example, many observers believe Indonesia's post-Suharto reforms gave courts too much independence too quickly without accountability, leading to the current problems with corruption. This contrast helps to explain China's current approach.
Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law Promotion is definitely worth a read, whether or not your interests are centered around China, if only to get a different perspective on courts.
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful.
Is there such a thing?
By Hans Dieter Wulf
Well, yes from a communist point of view. If you try to compare the judicial independence in China to an western system of judicial independence, there will be great divides, but if you study it in context with China's communist government, it is revealing indeed. Still one must be devoted to this subject to get through it. I would recommend it to the State Department, if they have not already discovered it.
Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press PDF
Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press EPub
Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press Doc
Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press iBooks
Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press rtf
Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press Mobipocket
Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law PromotionFrom Cambridge University Press Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar